Having a cyber incident response plan is one thing. Knowing whether it will work when you need it is another. Arcanum Cyber Sales Lead, Chris Hanwell, explores how tabletop exercises can help organisations test their preparedness, identify weaknesses and improve their ability to respond to a cyber incident.
Imagine arriving at work to discover that several critical systems are unavailable. Employees can’t access essential files, operations are being disrupted and there’s growing concern that your organisation has suffered a ransomware attack.
What happens next?
Who has the authority to disconnect affected systems? When should senior leadership be informed? And how do you communicate if your usual channels are unavailable?
These questions should be addressed within an organisation’s Incident Response Plan (IRP). But having the answers written down doesn’t necessarily mean people will know what to do when an incident occurs.
That’s where tabletop exercises can make a real difference and why a growing number of our clients at Arcanum are asking us to help them organise and deliver these sessions.
What is a cyber incident response tabletop exercise?
A tabletop exercise is a structured, discussion-based simulation that allows organisations to work through a realistic cyber incident without disrupting live systems.
Participants are presented with a hypothetical scenario, such as a ransomware attack, data breach or compromised supplier. As the situation develops, they’re asked what actions they would take, who would be responsible and how decisions would be made.
Unlike penetration testing, which assesses technical security weaknesses, tabletop exercises focus on the people, processes and decisions involved in responding to an incident.
The objective isn’t to catch people out. In fact, it’s essential to make this clear from the start of any programme of works. The goal is instead to establish whether an organisation’s response arrangements are practical, well understood and effective.
Five benefits of tabletop exercises
1. Clarifying roles and responsibilities
During a cyber incident, decisions often need to be made quickly, sometimes with incomplete information.
Who can authorise systems to be disconnected? Who decides whether operations should continue? When does the board become involved?
Tabletop exercises help establish whether responsibilities are understood and identify situations where decisions lack a clear owner.
2. Identifying gaps in response plans
An Incident Response Plan can look perfectly reasonable on paper until it’s tested.
Perhaps the plan relies on contacting someone who’s unavailable. Maybe a critical supplier isn’t included in escalation procedures. Or alternative communication arrangements depend on the very systems affected by the incident.
Exercises expose these assumptions, allowing organisations to address weaknesses before they’re encountered for real.
3. Testing decision-making under pressure
Cyber incidents rarely unfold predictably. Consider a ransomware attack affecting a manufacturer. Disconnecting systems might contain the threat, but what happens if those systems support critical production processes?
A well-designed tabletop exercise introduces new developments throughout the scenario, requiring participants to assess changing circumstances and consider the consequences of their decisions.
4. Improving communication and coordination
Effective incident response involves more than IT. Senior leaders, operations, legal, communications and external specialists may all have important roles to play.
Tabletop exercises bring these responsibilities together, testing how information is shared, incidents are escalated and decisions are communicated.
They can also establish whether the organisation could coordinate its response if normal communication channels became unavailable.
5. Building confidence and resilience
Responding to a serious cyber incident can be unfamiliar territory, particularly for those outside IT and security teams. Tabletop exercises give participants experience of working through difficult scenarios in a controlled environment.
Regular exercises help teams become more familiar with their responsibilities, improve coordination and build confidence in their ability to respond.
Getting the most from tabletop exercises
Simply discussing a hypothetical cyber attack isn’t necessarily enough. Exercises should reflect the organisation’s operating environment, critical systems, business priorities and likely threats.
They should have clear objectives, involve the right decision-makers and introduce realistic developments that challenge existing assumptions. Importantly, the exercise shouldn’t end when the scenario finishes. A structured debrief should identify what worked, what didn’t and where improvements are needed. Actions should be documented, assigned to individuals and followed through.
Exercises should also be repeated periodically, with scenarios varied to reflect changes in technology, operations and the threat landscape.
Putting incident response plans into practice
No organisation can eliminate cyber risk entirely. Strong preventative controls are essential, but businesses must also prepare for situations where those controls aren’t enough.
An Incident Response Plan provides the framework for managing an incident. Tabletop exercises help establish whether that framework works in practice. Because the first time you test your response arrangements shouldn’t be during a real cyber attack.
Get in touch with the team here at Arcanum today to discuss your organisation’s cyber incident response preparedness. Book a call.